- Insights
- Public Procurement
- Lowest Price vs Quality: How Québec Tenders Are Scored
Lowest Price vs Quality: How Québec Tenders Are Scored
Key Takeaways
- Québec public tenders are awarded in one of a few ways: lowest price, lowest price among bids that pass a quality bar, lowest adjusted price (quality-price ratio), or, for municipalities, a quality score weighted by price. The tender package states which one applies.
- Under the provincial regulations, a quality-price evaluation scores each criterion out of 100, requires at least 70 overall, and divides your price by 1 + K × (quality score − 70) / 30, with K set in the package.
- Municipal professional-services contracts usually use the deferred-price system: at least four criteria, no criterion worth more than 30 points, a 70-point pass mark before your price envelope is even opened, and a price factor between 0 and 50 that stays secret until the opening.
Every Québec public tender is evaluated in one of a few ways: lowest price, lowest price among bids that clear a quality bar, lowest price once it has been adjusted for quality, or, for municipalities, a quality score weighted by price. The tender package states the method up front. It decides whether a sharper price or a stronger technical offer wins, so it should shape both your go/no-go decision and your bid.
Which evaluation methods apply to Québec public tenders?
Two sets of rules are in play, depending on who is buying.
Provincial public bodies (government departments, school service centres, the health network and the other bodies covered by the Act respecting contracts by public bodies) follow the Règlement sur les contrats de travaux de construction des organismes publics and the Règlement sur les contrats de services des organismes publics. We read both in September 2026 in their LégisQuébec consolidation, current to May 1, 2026. Together they set out four methods:
- Lowest price. The construction regulation’s starting point is that the buyer asks only for a price, and the lowest price among compliant bids wins. The services regulation applies the same default to contracts for technical services.
- Minimum quality, then lowest price. Your offer is checked against at least three criteria. Every criterion has to reach the “acceptable performance level” described in the package, or the bid is rejected. Among the bids that pass, the lowest price wins.
- Lowest adjusted price (quality-price ratio). Quality is scored, and that score adjusts your price. The lowest adjusted price wins.
- Quality only. Used for professional services when a tariff fixes the fee. The best acceptable quality score wins. For architecture and engineering services tied to construction, the services regulation also allows a quality evaluation followed by price negotiation with the top-ranked firm, as well as design competitions.
For professional services, the services regulation’s rule is that the buyer evaluates quality. Price and the quality demonstration are submitted separately, and a selection committee of at least three members plus a secretary scores quality without seeing the price.
Municipal bodies have followed the Loi sur les contrats des organismes municipaux (LCOM) since it came into force on April 1, 2026, a date confirmed by both the UMQ and the FQM. It replaced the contracting provisions of the Loi sur les cités et villes and the Code municipal, so guides citing those articles are out of date. The LCOM lists the award procedures, including the lowest-priced compliant bid, a price request to qualified firms, a global criteria evaluation system and a deferred price knowledge system (système de connaissance différée du prix). According to the FQM, the global system succeeds the old one-envelope weighting method and the deferred-price system succeeds the two-envelope method. Under section 31, a municipal professional-services contract that has to go through an open procedure or a written invitation must use one of these quality-based routes, or, for engineering, architecture or design, a competition.
How the adjusted price is calculated
Annex 2 of the services regulation and Annex 5 of the construction regulation set the same scoring mechanics:
- At least three quality criteria, each weighted by importance, with the weights adding up to 100%.
- Each criterion is scored from 0 to 100. The “acceptable performance level” equals 70 points.
- The package may require a minimum of 70 on specific criteria. Missing one means rejection.
- Your final quality score is the weighted sum. A bid needs at least 70 to count as acceptable.
- Your price is then adjusted:
Adjusted price = Price submitted ÷ [1 + K × (Final quality score − 70) / 30]
K is the extra percentage the buyer is willing to pay to move from a 70-point bid to a 100-point bid. The buyer sets it in the package. Under the services regulation it must be between 15% and 30%. Under the construction regulation it is also 15% to 30% for construction work, and up to 40% for a mixed construction and professional-services contract.
Here is an illustration with invented numbers and K set at 20%. Firm A bids $500,000 and scores 75, which gives a coefficient of 1.033 and an adjusted price of about $483,900. Firm B bids $540,000 and scores 90, which gives a coefficient of 1.133 and an adjusted price of about $476,500. Firm B wins while charging $40,000 more. The 15-point quality gap was worth roughly 9.7% of price at that K.
How the municipal deferred-price system works
This is the two-envelope system most municipal engineers and professionals know, now written into sections 43 and 66 to 72 of the LCOM:
- The bid is evaluated on at least four criteria, and no criterion may be worth more than 30 points out of 100. Price has to be in a separate document.
- The price is not read aloud at the opening. The selection committee (at least three members who are not council members, plus a secretary, and whose identities are confidential) scores each bid without knowing its price.
- A bid with an interim score under 70, or one that misses a per-criterion minimum set in the package, is rejected. Its price envelope is returned unopened, or destroyed unread if it came through SEAO.
- For the remaining bids, final score = (interim score + factor) × 10,000 ÷ price. The highest final score wins.
The factor falls somewhere between 0 and 50. The municipality has to set it before publishing the tender, but section 67 says it is disclosed only after the bids are opened. A higher factor dilutes quality differences, so price matters more.
Take the same invented firms. Firm A scores 75 and bids $500,000. Firm B scores 90 and bids $580,000. With a factor of 0, B wins (1.55 against 1.50). With a factor of 50, A wins (2.50 against 2.41). You cannot know in advance which case you are in, so test your bid at both ends of the range.
How to read the evaluation grid in the tender package
The grid is usually in the instructions to bidders or in an appendix. Our guide on reading a SEAO notice covers the notice itself, but the grid is where the award is really decided. Before you price anything, pull out five things:
- The method. Is it lowest price, minimum quality, adjusted price, deferred price, or global evaluation? That wording tells you which formula applies.
- K or the factor. In a provincial tender, K is published. A K of 30% rewards quality much more than a K of 15%. For a municipal deferred-price tender, remember that you will not see the factor before the opening.
- The criteria and their weights. A criterion worth 30 points (or 30%) deserves three times the pages and proof of one worth 10.
- The elimination thresholds. Note every minimum score and every criterion that has to reach “acceptable”. One weak section can sink the whole bid.
- What “acceptable” means for each criterion. The package has to describe the elements required to reach 70. That description is your checklist.
How the method changes your go/no-go decision
The method changes which of the questions in our go/no-go decision framework matters most.
- Lowest price: you win on cost structure, so the question is whether you can be the cheapest compliant bidder without pricing yourself into a loss.
- Minimum quality, then lowest price: the quality bar is pass/fail. Clear it with room to spare, then compete on price exactly as you would under lowest price.
- Adjusted price: estimate how many quality points you can realistically earn compared with the likely field. Every 10 points above 70 is worth roughly K ÷ 3 of price. At K = 30%, that is 10%. An experienced firm with strong references can win without being the cheapest, and a new entrant has to be cheaper to make up for a thinner file.
- Deferred price: the 70-point bar is eliminatory and the factor is unknown. Bid only if you can clearly clear 70, and make sure your price still holds up if the factor turns out to be 50.
How to write the technical offer
The committee scores what is on the page and nothing else. Your reputation with the buyer counts for nothing unless it is documented.
- Follow the grid’s structure. Use one section per criterion, in the grid’s order, with the grid’s own headings.
- Answer the “acceptable” description point by point, then show what goes beyond it. Scores above 70 come from specific proof: comparable projects with dates and values, named key personnel with relevant experience, a work plan built around this project.
- Give pages in proportion to the points. Do not write four pages on company history for a 10-point criterion and one page of methodology for a 30-point one.
- Keep price out of the quality envelope. Price and quality must be submitted separately, and under the construction regulation’s adjusted-price section, the package must state that failing to do so means automatic rejection. See the errors that get a bid rejected.
Once the bids are in, the results you receive depend on the method. Under the services regulation, an adjusted-price bidder is told its quality score, adjusted price and rank. What happens between the deadline and the award is covered in bid opening and results.
Find the tenders where your strengths are scored
Quality-based evaluation is common in professional services tenders and engineering tenders. The quickest way to see which tenders match your trade and territory is the free SEAO Profile: set your trade and region once, then read the evaluation grid before deciding to bid.
Alliance Optima is not affiliated with SEAO or the Government of Québec. The regulations and the LCOM are summarized here as read in September 2026. The tender package and its addenda always govern, so check the method, K or factor, and thresholds in the documents at seao.gouv.qc.ca before bidding.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the lowest bid always win a Québec public tender?
No. Construction contracts under the provincial construction regulation are awarded on price alone by default, but a public body may evaluate quality instead, and professional-services contracts are evaluated on quality as a rule. Whatever the method, a non-compliant bid never wins.
What is the adjusted price in a Québec tender?
It is your price divided by a quality coefficient equal to 1 + K × (your quality score − 70) / 30. K is the percentage extra the buyer is willing to pay to go from a 70-point bid to a 100-point bid. Under the services and construction regulations read in September 2026, K must be between 15% and 30%, or up to 40% for a mixed construction and professional-services contract.
What happens if my technical offer scores under 70 on a municipal tender?
Under the Loi sur les contrats des organismes municipaux, a bid with an interim score under 70, or one that misses a per-criterion minimum set in the package, is rejected. The price envelope is returned unopened, or destroyed unread if it was filed through SEAO.
Can I find out the municipal price factor before I bid?
No. The municipality has to set the factor, somewhere between 0 and 50, before the tender is published, but the law says it is disclosed only after the bids are opened. Test your bid against both ends of the range.
Which public tenders fit your business?
Tell us your trade, territory and contract size. Your free SEAO Profile™ ranks the open tenders that match, with a score that explains itself, in two minutes.
Get My Free SEAO Profile™Follow Alliance Optima in Google
Add us as a preferred source and our analysis shows up more often in your Google results and AI answers.
Add as a preferred source